1.中国人民公安大学侦查学院;2.公安部鉴定中心,法医遗传学公安部重点实验室,北京市现场物证检验工程技术研究中心, 现场物证溯源技术国家工程实验室;3.金昌市公安局金川分局;4.甘肃省公安厅刑事侦查总队
R89;D919.2
中央级公益性科研院所基本科研业务费专项资金 2025JB031 2026JB025
1.School of Investigation, People'2.'3.s Public Security University of China;4.Institute of Forensic Science, Key Laboratory of Forensic Genetics, Beijing Engineering Research Center of Crime Scene Evidence Examination, National Engineering Laboratory for Forensic Science;5.Jinchuan Branch of Jinchang Public Security Bureau;6.Gansu Provincial Public Security Department Criminal Investigation Corps
the Fundamental Research Funds for Basic Scientific Research 2025JB031 2026JB025
混合生物检材中的不同贡献者拆分是法医遗传学领域长期面临的核心技术挑战之一,拆分准确性直接影响案件侦破效率与司法公正性。本文以是否需要依托拆分软件为界限,系统梳理了现有的两类混合生物检材拆分策略:一是基于生物实验的检材前处理策略,通过显微可视化分选进行不同来源细胞的物理分离与独立检测,或通过特异性物理化学处理在检测前实现区分;二是基于计算生物学的数据后处理策略,借助生物信息学算法对混合DNA检测数据进行拆分,从而实现贡献者组分的精准区分。在此基础上总结了两类策略的学术争议及优劣对比,评估其在法医学实践中的适用场景及局限性,并结合基层实战中检材条件多样、检验资源有限等特点,提出了基于样本质量评估的分级应用策略及多策略联合应用路径。最后,对未来混合检材快检设备的发展路径和人工智能在混合拆分中的应用前景进行展望,以期为混合生物检材的精准解析提供系统的方法学参考。
The deconvolution of contributors from mixed biological samples represents a long-standing core technical challenge in the field of forensic genetics, as the accuracy of this process directly impacts case investigation efficiency and judicial fairness. Based on whether the deconvolution relies on software as a boundary, this paper systematically reviews the two existing types of strategies for deconvoluting mixed biological samples. (1) Pre-processing strategies based on biological experiments, which achieve physical separation and independent detection of cells from different sources through microscope-guided single-cell isolation, or accomplish differentiation prior to detection via specific physicochemical treatments. Among these, physical separation based on differences in cell morphology mainly employs cell capture techniques characterized by low-to-medium throughput but high precision, using visualization tools such as microscopes for single-cell isolation, followed by specialized detection of the isolated cells. Chemical separation based on differences in biochemical properties mainly targets different body fluids and can directly link a body fluid to its contributing source, including differential lysis, as well as coding-region single nucleotide polymorphisms (cSNPs) and some compound markers. (2) post-processing strategies based on computational biology, which rely on bioinformatics algorithms to analyze mixed DNA testing data, enabling precise discrimination of contributor components. Among these, deconvolution based on probabilistic models mainly depends on probabilistic genotyping software (PGS), currently including software that applies two core algorithms: Markov chain Monte Carlo methods (MCMC) and maximum likelihood estimation (MLE). While clustering-based deconvolution relies on single-cell RNA sequencing (scRNA-seq) and single-cell ATAC sequencing (scATAC-seq), in which each cell is labeled with a distinct barcode, thereby allowing deconvolution of the resulting data and classification of each cell into its cell population of origin. On this basis, this paper summarizes the academic debates, advantages, and disadvantages of the two deconvolution strategies, evaluates their applicable scenarios and limitations in forensic practice, and proposes a graded application strategy based on sample quality assessment, as well as a pathway for the integrated use of the different deconvolution strategies, taking into account the diverse conditions of forensic exhibits and limited resources in routine forensic casework: for sperm-vaginal fluid mixed stains, differential lysis is preferentially adopted to obtain single-source male and female profiles. If same-sex contributors are involved, PGS is further used for deconvolution. For mixed samples that are conventional in amount and well preserved, PGS can be used for post-processing deconvolution after routine STR profiling. For mixed samples that are trace, aged, and poorly preserved, it is necessary to introduce linear amplification via transposon insertion (LIANTI) or primary template-directed amplification (PTA) for whole genome amplification (WGA) on the basis of isolated cells, thereby creating conditions for obtaining STR profiles. Finally, this paper looks forward to the future development of rapid testing instruments for mixed forensic samples and the promising applications of artificial intelligence in mixture deconvolution: the former includes the integration of microfluidic chips, the field deployment of portable nanopore sequencing and its combined use with PGS, while the latter includes the application of artificial intelligence technologies such as deep learning models and multimodal large language models, aiming to provide a methodological reference for the accurate deconvolution of mixed biological samples.
高静,臧丽丽,王春年,贾镇,刘京,江丽,李彩霞.混合生物检材的拆分策略及其法医学应用[J].生物化学与生物物理进展,,():
复制

扫码关注 生物化学与生物物理进展 ® 2026 网站版权 ICP:京ICP备05023138号-1 京公网安备 11010502031771号
